ANN ARBOR, Mich. — Michigan’s season had not gone according to plan, but with a victory against Ohio State, much would be forgiven. Now, having just scored, with 32 seconds left, needing only an extra point to tie the game, Michigan Coach Brady Hoke decided to go for the 2-point conversion, to try to salvage the season by dashing Ohio State’s dreams of an undefeated season and a national championship.
But quarterback Devin Gardner threw an interception, sealing No. 3 Ohio State’s 42-41 win, the Buckeyes’ ninth in the last 10 years in the rivalry.
Braxton Miller, Ohio State’s quarterback, accounted for five touchdowns. Carlos Hyde ran for 226 yards. And Coach Urban Meyer improved to 24-0 in two seasons at Ohio State (12-0, 8-0 Big Ten).
If not for the tattoo-parlor scandal, in which players received cash and tattoos in exchange for memorabilia, and the subsequent bowl ban issued by the N.C.A.A., Ohio State might have played in last year’s national championship game. To make it this year, the Buckeyes will have to beat Michigan State next week in the Big Ten Championship game and hope for stumbles by either No. 1 Alabama, which played rival Auburn in a later game Saturday, or No. 2 Florida State, which plays in next week’s Atlantic Coast Conference championship game. Michigan (7-5, 3-5) was supposed to be the least of Ohio State’s worries.
Instead, Michigan made the game interesting from the start.
When Jeremy Gallon took a screen pass 84 yards, setting up a touchdown, on Michigan’s opening drive, Miller responded with a 53-yard touchdown pass to Devin Smith. When Michigan scored again, Miller responded with a nifty 53-yard touchdown run. This Michigan team, which had been sort of sleepwalking all season only to wake up now, for Ohio State, then scored on a 17-yard pass to Gallon.
Michigan had lost four games entering Saturday, and easily could have lost three more — to Akron, Connecticut, and Northwestern. Then Jabrill Peppers, a prized recruit who had committed to Michigan, tweeted this week that he would take more official visits, apparently just in case Hoke was fired. Dave Brandon, the athletic director, felt it was necessary to make a statement, firmly backing Hoke.
If anything, Hoke, along with the arrival of Meyer at Ohio State, has reignited this rivalry. Hoke constantly refers to Ohio State as “Ohio.” And Meyer apologized when he accidentally said “Michigan” during a news conference, a word that is rarely uttered. His wife later tweeted a picture of a bar of soap, implying he had washed out his mouth.
On the ensuing kickoff after Gallon’s touchdown, Dontre Wilson, the Ohio State return man, got up and was surrounded by at least seven Michigan players. A few of Wilson’s teammates joined the scrum. Then someone started shoving, punches were thrown, four flags went flying, and an Ohio State helmet rolled away.
For Michigan, Royce Jenkins-Stone, a backup linebacker, was ejected. For Ohio State, Wilson, and the starting right guard, Marcus Hall, were ejected. As Hall walked up the tunnel leaving the stadium, he made a vulgar gesture to the crowd.
But the crowd was splotched with scarlet and gray. The Ohio State faithful groaned when Miller threw an interception after the fight, and cheered as Miller scrambled for a 21-yard touchdown just before halftime, tying the score, 21-21.
And this iteration of The Game, as it is called, was supposed to be a blowout, just another game to add to Ohio State’s undefeated streak. The Buckeyes had scored 48.7 points per game, third most in the country, behind only Baylor and Florida State. Each week, the blowouts seemed to get bigger. Ohio State needed to win, and win big, if it was to overcome a weak schedule and jump teams in the rankings.
In the third quarter, Miller jogged into the end zone, basically untouched, on a 3-yard touchdown run. He and Hyde kept running. Then Miller faked a handoff to Hyde and found Jeff Heuerman, wide open for a 22-yard touchdown to take a 35-21 lead.
Michigan slowly mounted a comeback in fourth quarter. Gardner found Drew Dileo for an 11-yard touchdown, and then Hyde fumbled, leading to another Michigan touchdown, a 2-yard pass to Jake Butt that tied the score, 35-35.
On the next play from scrimmage, Miller ran for 32 yards, and five plays later, Hyde scored the go-ahead touchdown. But more than two minutes remained. Gardner led Michigan on a 11-play, 84-yard drive capped by a two-yard touchdown pass to the tight end Devin Funchess. Then Michigan decided to go for the win.